What plants do not like coco coir?

picture of Seamus OConnell
Seamus OConnell
picture of Malcolm Reeves
Malcolm Reeves
Published:
Updated:

The young blueberry in a coir-heavy pot by my back fence sulked all spring. Its leaves turned a sickly yellow between the veins and new growth stalled. I dug it out and moved it into an acidic peat-based mix, and within three weeks the green came back and fresh shoots pushed out. The plants that dislike coir are the acid-loving ones, and that little bush showed me why in real time.

Acid-loving plants are the main group that struggles in pure coco coir. These plants pull nutrients best from a sour root zone, and coir does not give them that. Coco coir works as a fine growing medium for your tomatoes, peppers, herbs, and most houseplants. It drains well and resists rot, so you can lean on it for the bulk of your garden. But it sits in the wrong range for the picky few that crave acid, and forcing them into it only sets you up for trouble.

You can spot the problem before you even buy the plant. Check the care tag for the words ericaceous or acid-loving, and check the target pH if it lists one. If the number sits below 5.5, that plant wants peat, not coir. Knowing this up front saves you from potting a healthy nursery shrub into a mix that will starve it. I keep a short list of these picky growers taped inside my potting shed for this reason.

Here is the technical reason. Coir tends to sit near pH 5.2 to 6.8, which is close to neutral. Acid-lovers want a much sourer root zone, roughly pH 4.5 to 5.5. At the higher pH of coir, iron and a few other nutrients lock up and the roots cannot take them in. That is what causes the yellow leaves with green veins you see on a starving blueberry. The plant is hungry even when the food is right there.

A handful of well-known shrubs fall into this camp. Blueberries and azaleas lead the list, and they suffer fast in near-neutral coir. You can add rhododendrons to the group, plus camellias and cranberries. All of them grew up in acidic, peaty ground, and none has adjusted to a sweeter mix. Plant any of these in straight coir and you will watch the same slow decline I saw by my fence.

Acid-Lovers That Reject Coir
PlantBlueberryTarget pH
4.5 to 5.5
Sign Of TroubleYellow leaves, green veins
PlantAzaleaTarget pH
4.5 to 5.5
Sign Of TroublePale, stunted growth
PlantRhododendronTarget pH
4.5 to 5.5
Sign Of TroubleLeaf yellowing
PlantCamelliaTarget pH
5.0 to 5.5
Sign Of TroubleWeak buds, dull foliage
PlantCranberryTarget pH
4.0 to 5.0
Sign Of TroublePoor fruit, thin runners

So what should you do? Reach for peat or an acidic potting mix made for these plants instead of fighting coir's near-neutral nature. Peat moss holds a low pH on its own, the kind that blueberries and their cousins love, which is why nurseries pot them in it. You can find bagged ericaceous mixes built for exactly this group at most garden centers. Grab one of those, and your shrubs settle in without a fuss.

If you already have coir on hand and want to use it, you can still acidify the medium. Mix in a little elemental sulfur to nudge the soil pH down toward the right band. You can also water with a diluted acidifier for a faster drop. Test the result with a cheap meter before you plant anything. Then check it again every few weeks, since coir drifts back up over time. For most growers, though, starting with peat is the easier path, and it saves you all that constant correcting and re-testing down the line.

Read the full article: Coco Coir: A Practical Garden Guide

Continue reading