I have watched the Bloodgood in the part-shade bed beside my patio hold deep red leaves for four summers running. It sits in my zone 6 mid-Atlantic garden and gets clean morning light, then cool shade by early afternoon. I planted an earlier one in the open front yard, and it scorched and thinned out before its second August. That spot baked in full sun all day, with no relief and no afternoon break. The two trees came from the same nursery, the same size, the same year. Only the light was different.
So the bloodgood maple sun shade answer depends on where you live. In cool northern zones it takes full sun and keeps strong color. In hot southern regions it needs partial afternoon shade to stay healthy. The same tree wants different light in zone 5 than it does in zone 8, and getting that match right is the whole game.
Light is not really the thing your tree cares about. Heat and water are. A Bloodgood in too much sun loses moisture from its leaves faster than the roots can replace it. Japanese maple leaf scorch is the result, and it shows up as brown, crispy leaf edges by midsummer. The RHS notes that scorch comes from lack of soil moisture or too much exposure, not sun alone.
That is why wind and drought matter as much as the sun does. Excess sun, dry wind, and thin soil all pull water out of the leaves the same way. A tree in part shade with steady moisture handles heat far better than one in full sun on dry ground. Cool roots and damp soil let the leaves keep up with whatever light they get. Think of sun as the demand and water as the supply. When demand runs ahead of supply, the edges burn. My front-yard tree did not fail because of the sun by itself. It failed because the open spot was hot, breezy, and quick to dry out, and the roots could never catch up.
The extension sources back this split. UF/IFAS says to plant in partial shade in the southern part of the range, though the tree may take more direct sun farther north. The RHS adds that leaf color is best in partial shade, even where full sun works. So a little shade does double duty in warm gardens. It guards against scorch and it deepens the red you bought the tree for in the first place.
Match your spot to your USDA zone and you will not have to guess. In zones 5 to 6, full sun gives you the best color and a dense canopy. The cooler air keeps the leaves from drying out, so the tree can take all the light it gets. In zones 7b to 8, give the tree morning sun and afternoon shade from a building, fence, or taller tree. The east side of a house works well, since it catches gentle early light and falls into shadow once the day heats up. Bloodgood grows happily across zones 5a to 8b once the light fits the heat.
Wherever you plant, keep the soil evenly moist, especially in the first two years and during dry spells. A two to three inch mulch ring holds water and keeps roots cool, which does more to stop scorch than shade alone. Get the water steady and the light matched to your zone, and a Bloodgood rewards you with clean red leaves from spring through fall.
Read the full article: Bloodgood Japanese Maple Care Guide