You should not cut the top off a tulip poplar tree. The short answer to topping a tulip poplar is no. Cutting the crown sets off a chain of problems, and you end up with a weaker, more dangerous tree than you started with. Topping feels like an easy fix for a tree that got too tall. It is the opposite.
A crew sawed off the crown of the poplar two doors down from my own old Tennessee lot. That spring I checked on it and found a thick brush of skinny, upright shoots. From the street it looked like a green broom stuck on a bare trunk. The next big storm rolled through that summer. Half those shoots tore loose at once. They rained branches across the driveway and the neighbor's fence.
Here is the biology behind that mess. When you cut a major leader, the tree panics. It floods the cut area with watersprouts, a dense crowd of fast, weak shoots that race upward to replace the lost leaves. These shoots attach at the surface instead of deep in the wood. So they snap off in wind once they get any size. That is the core of tree topping damage, and it shows up within a year or two.
The wounds are the other half of the harm. A topping cut leaves a wide, flat stub. The tree cannot seal that over the way it seals a small, clean cut. Water, fungi, and insects move into the open face, and rot works its way down the trunk. Tulip poplar wood is light and brittle to begin with. So decay spreads fast, and the trunk grows hollow while the top still looks green and alive. By the time you spot it, you often have a hazard right over your house.
You also cannot shrink this tree by cutting it. Your tulip poplar is built by its genes to be big, reaching 70 to 120 feet (21 to 37 meters) at maturity. Top it and you only push it to climb back to that height with worse, faster wood. The size is locked in. So no amount of cutting on your part turns it into a small yard tree, and you waste money trying.
The right way to shape one is gentle and early. Good tulip tree pruning starts while the tree is young. That is when you set a single strong central leader and a balanced spread of limbs. Do this work in late winter or early spring while the tree is dormant. Cut before the leaves push out so the wounds seal cleanly. The tree then wastes no energy on repair during its growing months.
Once your tree matures, leave the crown alone. Remove only dead, broken, or crossing limbs that rub and create new wounds. Keep every cut small, and make it back to a branch collar, not a random stub in open wood. Your mature poplar holds together far better in storms when you treat it this way than any topped one ever will.
The real fix happens before you ever plant. This tree needs room, so put it where the full height fits. Keep it clear of power lines, roofs, and fences from day one. Give it 30 feet of clearance from the house and you never face the topping question at all. Plant it in a tight spot and even perfect pruning will not save you. You cannot prune your way out of a tree that was put in the wrong place. So pick the spot first, and let the tree grow the way it was built to grow.
Read the full article: Tulip Poplar Tree: A Complete Guide