What is the most common mistake in tree planting?

picture of Nkechi Adebayo
Nkechi Adebayo
picture of Leonard Cartwright
Leonard Cartwright
Published:
Updated:

The common tree planting mistake that kills more young trees than anything else is planting them too deep. Walk past a row of struggling saplings and you will spot it fast. The trunk goes straight into the ground like a fence post, with no widening base in sight. That widening base is the root flare, and on your tree it should sit right at the soil line where you can see it.

Look at sick young trees and the pattern repeats. Plums get hit hard by this. The flare is hidden under two inches of dirt, or worse, buried under a tall cone of mulch piled against the bark. Planting tree too deep is easy to do, and even easier to miss once you fill the hole back in. You bury the problem before you ever see it.

Depth matters because of what happens to your roots underground. Roots need air, not just water, and burying them deep cuts off the oxygen they depend on. Your flare and lower bark were never built to sit in wet soil. Cover them and they start to rot, which opens the door to disease and fungus at the trunk. A tree fighting all that puts almost nothing into new growth, so you watch it sit there for years instead of taking off.

Quick Field Check

Brush the soil away from the base of the trunk. If you cannot find the spot where the trunk widens and the first big roots spread out, the tree is planted too deep and needs to come up.

The fix is simple once you know the target. Set the tree so the root flare sits at or just above the soil line. Dig a hole no deeper than the root ball itself, but two to three times as wide. A wide, shallow hole gives roots loose soil to spread into while keeping the crown high and dry. If you dig too deep by accident, pack firm soil back in and rest the root ball on that pad so it cannot sink later.

Plums add one more catch. Utah State Extension notes that plums struggle in wet, heavy soils, where roots drown and the buried bark rots even faster. Pick a spot with good drainage. If your yard holds water after a storm, plant on a slight mound a few inches high so the base stays above the soggy zone. Drainage and depth work together, and getting both right saves the tree.

Plant At The Right Depth
1
Find The Flare

Before you dig, brush off any loose soil or potting mix until you see the trunk widen into the first roots.

2
Match The Hole

Measure the root ball from the flare to the bottom, then dig a hole that deep and three times as wide.

3
Set And Check

Place the tree, lay a stick across the hole, and confirm the flare sits level with or just above the ground.

4
Mulch The Right Way

Spread mulch in a flat ring two to three inches deep and pull it back so none of it touches the trunk.

Mulch deserves its own warning. A tall cone packed against the bark, often called volcano mulching, traps moisture right where you least want it and quietly rots your trunk. Keep your mulch flat and off the bark. Leave a few inches of bare soil around the base so the wood can breathe and your flare stays visible.

Nail the root flare planting depth and most other early problems fade on their own. Find the flare first, keep your hole no deeper than the root ball, skip the mulch volcano, and give the tree well-drained ground. Do those four things and your plum spends its energy growing instead of fighting to survive its own planting hole.

Read the full article: Plum Tree Guide: Grow, Harvest, and Eat

Continue reading