Last spring I planted out my whole front border and left it on nothing but rain. The native grevilleas and a clump of kangaroo paw filled out on their own. Meanwhile the corner I had fed bone meal for weeks looked the same as day one. That fed corner got no extra vigor at all. Same height, same color, same tired leaves. I kept walking past it and waiting for a payoff that never came.
The blood and bone plants that gain nothing fall into a few clear groups. The first group is your established natives. The second is many of your succulents. The third is most acid loving plants, such as blueberries and the azalea by your fence. These plants want lean soil and a lower pH to thrive. Blood and bone raises phosphorus and nudges the soil the wrong way. So you waste the feed and you risk weak, floppy growth on top of it.
Here is the part that surprised me when I read up on it. Many of your natives from Australia and parts of South Africa grew up in old, worn soil. That soil holds barely any phosphorus at all. Over thousands of years your plants built roots that pull tiny amounts from the ground with help from soil fungi. Pour on a phosphorus-heavy feed and you flood a system that was tuned for scraps. Your plant cannot use the extra, and the rest just sits in your soil.
Those soil fungi matter far more than you might think. Mycorrhizal fungi wrap around your plant roots and trade water and minerals for sugar. It is a quiet partnership that runs under your feet all season. When phosphorus spikes, your plant stops feeding the fungi. The fungi then shrink back and fade. So your low phosphorus plants lose the very partner that kept them strong. The feed does not help here. It quietly takes something away.
Black or curled leaf tips on banksias, grevilleas, or hakeas often point to phosphorus burn, not a lack of food. Stop feeding and flush the soil with plain water for a few weeks.
Blood and bone brings more than phosphorus to your bed. It also adds a good dose of nitrogen. Some of your lean-soil plants do not want that either. Extra nitrogen pushes soft, fast leaf growth that flops over and draws aphids. I have watched my succulents puff up with too much water and split right down the side. Your natives stretch tall and weak instead of staying dense and tough the way they should. The plant looks busy but it is not healthy.
So which plants stay off the list for good? Skip blood and bone on established natives. Skip it on most succulents and cacti. Skip it on acid loving plants that sink their roots into peaty beds. Blueberries, camellias, and rhododendrons all sit in this camp. These plants do far better with a light mulch and a feed built for their needs. A general bone-based product does them no favors.
Match the feed to the plant instead of treating the whole yard the same. Heavy feeders like tomatoes, roses, and leafy greens do well on blood and bone. The lean-soil crowd does not. A simple soil test costs only a few dollars at the garden center. It shows your pH and your phosphorus level in plain numbers. Those numbers tell you exactly where to feed and where to hold back.
I now test a bed before I spread anything across it. That one habit saved me from feeding plants that never wanted the help. Feed the hungry plants and leave the lean-soil ones alone. Your natives will stay tough and your succulents will hold their shape. Your wallet keeps the fertilizer you would have wasted on plants that do better with nothing at all.
Read the full article: Bone Meal: The Honest Science Guide