What are the main disadvantages of bone meal?

picture of Seamus OConnell
Seamus OConnell
picture of Adrian Forsyth
Adrian Forsyth
Published:
Updated:

The main bone meal disadvantages are easy to list. The phosphorus only works in acidic soil. It adds zero potassium. It can hurt helpful soil life. And it pulls hungry animals straight into your beds. Picture a flower bed treated at dusk and dug up by morning. A curious dog smells the bone and tears through the soil all night. By sunrise your new plants are scattered across the lawn.

That last problem is more common than most labels admit. Bone meal attracts animals like dogs, raccoons, and skunks. To them it smells like food. The ASPCA says garden products like bone meal ranked among the top ten reasons for pet poison-control calls in 2017. A dog that wolfs down a pile of it can form a hard mass in the gut. That kind of mass often needs a vet to clear it out. So the risk is real, not just a mess on the lawn.

Of all the bone meal disadvantages, the biggest hidden flaw is soil pH. Bone meal holds its phosphorus in a mineral called apatite. That mineral only breaks down and feeds plants when the soil sits below pH 7.0. In neutral or alkaline ground the phosphorus stays locked up. It does little to nothing for your plants. So a lot of gardeners spread it where it cannot work. Then they wonder why their roots and blooms never improve. The bag worked fine. The soil was just wrong for it.

Bone meal is also not a complete fertilizer. It carries no potassium at all. The bag usually reads close to 3-15-0. That last zero is the potassium. It is also low in nitrogen, so the first number stays small. Plants use potassium to move water, fight disease, and build good fruit. Lean on bone meal alone and you starve your garden of one of the three main nutrients. The other two get fed while the third runs short.

Watch For This

Adding excess phosphorus to soil that already has enough can lock out iron and zinc, leaving leaves yellow even though the nutrients are right there in the ground.

Too much phosphorus causes trouble below the surface too. Excess phosphorus holds back the helpful fungi in your soil. These root fungi reach out and pull water and food into your plants. Washington State University notes that adding nutrients a plant does not need is wasteful. It can also injure soil life. When a plant senses plenty of phosphate, it stops feeding those fungi. The helpful network under the soil starts to fade away. Then your plant has to work harder for the same water.

The fix for all of this is simple. Run a soil test before you buy a single bag. The test tells you your pH. It also tells you if you even lack phosphorus. Most settled beds have plenty already. Say your test shows a real shortage and acidic soil. Then mix the bone meal into the soil instead of leaving it on top. Working it in buries the smell. That keeps dogs and raccoons from digging your bed up.

When you need to feed the whole plant, do not stop at bone meal. Pair it with a potassium source like kelp meal or greensand. That way you cover all three major nutrients at once. Bone meal is a narrow tool, not an all-purpose feed. Use it only where a test proves you need phosphorus. Your soil also has to be acidic enough to release it. Skip it everywhere else and you will save money and protect your soil life. For most beds, a balanced feed does the job better with far less hassle.

Read the full article: Bone Meal: The Honest Science Guide

Continue reading