Can you sprinkle bone meal on top of the soil?

picture of Seamus OConnell
Seamus OConnell
picture of Adrian Forsyth
Adrian Forsyth
Published:
Updated:

One spring I dusted a fresh layer of bone meal across the top of my front rose bed, raked it smooth, and went to bed happy. By morning the dogs had nosed half of it across the lawn and onto the patio. So yes, you can sprinkle bone meal on soil, but mixing it in works much better and saves you that mess.

A thin surface scatter is what most people mean by bone meal top dressing, and it does put the nutrient in roughly the right spot. The problem is that it just sits there. Rain and watering wash a little of it down, but most of the powder stays near the surface where your plant's roots cannot do much with it. You end up feeding the top of the soil instead of the plant you bought it for.

Bone meal is mostly phosphorus, and phosphorus barely moves once it hits the soil. It binds to soil particles within an inch or two of where it lands. So a dose you leave on top stays on top. On most shrubs and perennials the hungry feeder roots sit 6 to 12 inches down. The nutrient never reaches them in any useful amount. You get a slow trickle at best, and on heavy clay you may get almost nothing. That is a lot of bone meal doing nothing for the plant you fed.

That is the whole case for getting it down where the roots live. When you mix bone meal into soil, you put the phosphorus right in the root zone instead of leaving it stranded on the surface. Your roots take it up faster, the plant responds sooner, and you waste far less of the product on every application. The same scoop simply does more work for you when it is buried instead of scattered.

Placement is simple once you know the target. For a new plant, work a small handful into the bottom few inches of the planting hole. Then add a thin layer of plain soil so the roots do not sit straight on the powder. For an established bed, scratch the bone meal into the top 3 to 4 inches with a hand fork. Do not just dust it flat across the surface. Both methods get the powder into the soil rather than on it. Both also put it within reach of the roots that need it.

There is a real cost to leaving it exposed too. Dogs, cats, raccoons, and squirrels are drawn to the smell, since bone meal is made from ground animal bone. To them a fresh surface layer smells like a buried treat, so they dig. If you garden with pets or you live near wildlife, that thin dusting becomes an open invitation to tear up the bed. Working the powder down into the soil hides most of that scent and keeps your plants from getting flipped out of the ground overnight.

Quick Tip

If you must apply on top, rake the bone meal into the surface, cover it with a thin layer of soil or mulch, and water it in right away. That cuts the smell and stops most pets and wildlife from digging.

Surface dusting has its place for a fast feed on a bed you cannot dig into, like one packed with shallow-rooted perennials. In those spots a light top dressing beats not feeding at all. Just cover and water it in every time so it does not blow off or wash away. But when you have the choice, mix it in. Your plants get more of what they paid for, you waste less product, and your dogs leave the bed alone.

Read the full article: Bone Meal: The Honest Science Guide

Continue reading